Knowledge Federation 2008 Dialogue Maps Scientific community scenario Key Concepts Examples

Map Node Scientific community scenario url anchor

Question Node How to federate from individual profiles to a community profile? url anchor

Answer Node Through intelligent mappings between vocabularies (legends) which are proposed to the users (TopicSpace vision) url anchor

Pro Node Eventually where we'd want to get to; fully automated merging not part of the KF orientation url anchor

Con Node Not possible yet url anchor

Answer Node Agree on a common ontology that we all map to. url anchor

Pro Node This is the common ground, analogous to federated states. Federated doesn't mean we don't agree on some common ground. url anchor

Question Node How is this different from a Semantic Web approach? url anchor

Answer Node We value the process of discussion that lies behind the final artifact. We would preserve that rationale, make it public, and perhaps link it carefully into the artifact. url anchor
Con Node SW community has public online discourse too url anchor
Question Node Is this at the core of what makes the KF approach distinctive? url anchor
Question Shortcut Node Is this at the core of what makes the KF approach distinctive? url anchor
Answer Node Jack's account of the OWL/XTM debate at SRI: TM is basically frame-KR. There is no technical news. The difference is in attitude url anchor
Question Node Is a federation attitude enough to make a new community? url anchor
Answer Node No, insufficient url anchor
Answer Node Yes, sufficient url anchor
Question Node How does this paradigm reconfigure the "organization of the warriors" - the social structures? url anchor
Answer Node Examples of how new media have reshaped practices url anchor
Map Node Examples url anchor
Pro Node A set of values about what to do with socio-semantic technology url anchor
Question Node Does this raise the need for new technical solutions? url anchor
Pro Node Yes, it's a/the/next paradigm badly needed for today's challenges, and for future k-production url anchor
Con Node Maybe not, but our tools could lead to a paradigm shift in social practices url anchor
Reference Node Wikipedia and the Meaning of Truth url anchor
Reference: http://www.technologyreview.com/web/21558/?a=f
Con Node But "we've been doing KF for thousands of years"...? url anchor
Question Node But the net changes everything? url anchor
Answer Node Yes, as articulated by many people url anchor
Answer Node Fikes" Where's the news?" url anchor
Answer Node We have to avoid talking about a new paradigm! url anchor
Answer Node Moveable Type analogy: "we've been doing writing for years"... url anchor
Question Node If it is a new paradigm, can we clarify the attributes? url anchor
Answer Node Crafting compelling maps as social, communication/ negotiation artifacts url anchor
Answer Node Jack: Taking seriously the processes of crafting these artifacts: creating the "OS" capable of supporting "k-gardening UIs" url anchor
Pro Node Analogous to Linux and KDE/Gnome open source efforts - people may understand this better, though the metaphor is not quite right url anchor
Answer Node Jack: "I want to talk about Topic Management now, not Topic Mapping" url anchor
Question Node How does this relate to IM and KM? url anchor
Answer Node Jack: the OS will do all the things that humans can't do well url anchor
Answer Node Alex: unclear how this would be any different from a wholistic view of IM or KM: spans all levels of an infrastructure url anchor
Answer Node "Federate" should become a verb url anchor
Question Node DNA analogy: Subject Proxy and Property are the DNA of a memetic system...? url anchor
Question Node Design vs Emergence? url anchor
Answer Node Our services approach is probably not so different technically, but simply the kinds of work we want to support url anchor
Question Node Is a federation attitude enough to make a new community? url anchor
Answer Node No, insufficient url anchor
Answer Node Yes, sufficient url anchor
Question Node How does this paradigm reconfigure the "organization of the warriors" - the social structures? url anchor
Answer Node Examples of how new media have reshaped practices url anchor
Map Node Examples url anchor
Pro Node A set of values about what to do with socio-semantic technology url anchor
Question Node Does this raise the need for new technical solutions? url anchor
Pro Node Yes, it's a/the/next paradigm badly needed for today's challenges, and for future k-production url anchor
Con Node Maybe not, but our tools could lead to a paradigm shift in social practices url anchor
Reference Node Wikipedia and the Meaning of Truth url anchor
Reference: http://www.technologyreview.com/web/21558/?a=f
Con Node But "we've been doing KF for thousands of years"...? url anchor
Question Node But the net changes everything? url anchor
Answer Node Yes, as articulated by many people url anchor
Answer Node Fikes" Where's the news?" url anchor
Answer Node We have to avoid talking about a new paradigm! url anchor
Answer Node Moveable Type analogy: "we've been doing writing for years"... url anchor
Question Node If it is a new paradigm, can we clarify the attributes? url anchor
Answer Node Crafting compelling maps as social, communication/ negotiation artifacts url anchor
Answer Node Jack: Taking seriously the processes of crafting these artifacts: creating the "OS" capable of supporting "k-gardening UIs" url anchor
Pro Node Analogous to Linux and KDE/Gnome open source efforts - people may understand this better, though the metaphor is not quite right url anchor
Answer Node Jack: "I want to talk about Topic Management now, not Topic Mapping" url anchor
Question Node How does this relate to IM and KM? url anchor
Answer Node Jack: the OS will do all the things that humans can't do well url anchor
Answer Node Alex: unclear how this would be any different from a wholistic view of IM or KM: spans all levels of an infrastructure url anchor
Answer Node "Federate" should become a verb url anchor
Question Node DNA analogy: Subject Proxy and Property are the DNA of a memetic system...? url anchor
Question Node Design vs Emergence? url anchor
Question Shortcut Node Is this at the core of what makes the KF approach distinctive? url anchor
Answer Node Tanaka: "Knowledge Reorganization" as an alternative to Semantic Web Services approaches url anchor
Answer Node View federation url anchor
Top